Image related to Can You Sue Uber or Lyft After a Crash in California?

Can You Sue Uber or Lyft After a Crash in California?

Free Consultation
PARRIS Law FirmNewsPersonal Injury

Yes, you can sue Uber or Lyft after a crash in California, but it’s not always straightforward. Whether you can hold the company directly responsible depends on the driver’s status in the app, the insurance policies involved, and the specific facts of your case. Because these accidents often involve multiple parties and layers of coverage, having an experienced lawyer is critical.

Why Are Rideshare Accidents More Complicated Than Regular Car Crashes?

A typical car accident usually involves two drivers, two insurance companies, and a fairly direct question: who caused the crash? With rideshare accidents, the picture is much more complicated.

The first complicating factor is multiple parties. If you’re hurt in a rideshare accident, the at-fault driver might be the Uber or Lyft driver, another motorist, or even a combination of both. In some cases, liability can also extend to third parties, such as the company that manufactured defective brakes or the city responsible for dangerous road conditions. Sorting out who is legally responsible takes a careful investigation.

The second layer of complexity comes from the rideshare companies themselves. Uber and Lyft classify their drivers as independent contractors, not employees. That classification is intentional: it makes it harder for crash victims to hold the companies accountable for their drivers’ negligence. Victims often have to prove that Uber or Lyft’s own negligence played a role in the crash.

Unlike a normal car crash where only the driver’s personal auto insurance is at play, rideshare companies use tiered coverage systems. Coverage changes depending on whether the driver had the app off, was waiting for a ride request, or already had a passenger onboard.

This means the same accident could trigger completely different insurance outcomes depending on a few small details. For example, if the driver had just dropped off a passenger and hadn’t accepted a new ride yet, Uber or Lyft might provide only limited coverage, leaving you to battle with the driver’s personal insurer.

Rideshare companies are fierce defenders of their brand and bottom line. Uber and Lyft hire entire teams of lawyers whose sole job is to minimize payouts. They often dispute liability, question the extent of injuries, or argue over which insurance coverage applies. For victims, this means getting a fair settlement is far more challenging than in a typical auto accident.

When Can You Sue Uber or Lyft Directly?

Not every rideshare crash leads to a lawsuit against the company. The key is showing that Uber or Lyft’s own negligence contributed to the accident.

Companies can be liable for who they let on the road, even if drivers aren’t employees. If they approve a driver with a record of reckless driving, DUIs, or violence, they can be held responsible for negligent hiring. Keeping a driver active after repeated complaints or dangerous incidents creates exposure for negligent retention.

Liability can also stem from how the apps are designed. Uber and Lyft use algorithms that pressure drivers to accept rides in seconds, chase surge pricing, and drive long shifts without rest. These business choices can directly increase crash risk, making the companies accountable for unsafe operating conditions.

Another area of exposure is how they handle safety complaints. Both platforms receive constant reports from passengers. When serious warnings about reckless or impaired driving are ignored and that driver later causes harm, the company’s failure to act becomes part of the case.

How Does Rideshare Insurance Work in California?

Rideshare accidents hinge on one question: what was the driver doing in the app at the time of the crash? Uber and Lyft structure their insurance coverage around three distinct periods, and each one determines who pays and how much is available.

  • App Off: When the driver’s app is turned off, they are not considered to be working for Uber or Lyft. Any crash during this period is treated like a normal car accident. The driver’s personal auto insurance is the only coverage available, and Uber or Lyft play no role. If the driver is uninsured or underinsured, victims may face serious gaps in recovery.
  • App On, No Ride Accepted: Once the driver opens the app and is waiting for a ride request, limited rideshare insurance comes into play. In California, Uber and Lyft provide up to $50,000 per person for bodily injury, $100,000 per accident, and $25,000 for property damage. These limits are far lower than what is available during an active trip. If another driver causes the crash, their insurance applies first, and Uber or Lyft’s coverage only fills in when the other policy is insufficient.
  • Ride Accepted or Passenger Onboard: The highest level of protection applies once the driver has accepted a ride request or is transporting a passenger. During this period, Uber and Lyft provide up to $1 million in liability coverage for bodily injury and property damage. This policy covers not only passengers but also pedestrians, cyclists, and occupants of other vehicles harmed by the rideshare driver. In addition, uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage is often available, protecting victims if the at-fault driver lacks adequate insurance.

These distinctions matter because a small detail—whether the driver had tapped “accept” seconds before a crash—can change the insurance coverage dramatically. Victims who don’t understand these rules may be left chasing the wrong insurer or settling for less than they deserve. That’s why documenting the driver’s app status and ride history is one of the first steps in a rideshare accident case.

What Compensation Can You Recover?

Rideshare crashes often leave victims with serious financial and personal losses. California law allows recovery for both economic and non-economic damages, but the categories go far beyond medical bills.

Medical expenses form the foundation of most claims. This includes the ambulance ride, hospital care, surgeries, medication, and follow-up appointments.

But victims are also entitled to future medical costs when their injuries require ongoing treatment. That could mean months of physical therapy, assistive devices, or long-term care for permanent disabilities. These future costs often exceed the initial hospital bills, making them a crucial part of a complete claim.

Lost income can be a major source of financial recovery. Even a moderate injury can keep someone out of work for weeks, creating immediate financial pressure. More severe injuries may prevent a victim from returning to their old job or reduce their ability to work at all.

In those cases, damages for reduced earning capacity can be pursued. These claims rely on evidence such as employment records, wage history, and expert testimony to show what the victim would have earned if not for the crash.

Beyond financial harm, victims can seek damages for pain and suffering. This category covers the physical pain of the injuries, the emotional toll of recovery, and the loss of enjoyment of life. A broken leg that heals in months is one thing; a spinal injury that permanently limits mobility is another. The law recognizes these differences and allows for higher compensation when the impact is long-term or life-changing.

While often smaller than medical bills or lost wages, property damage recovery can still be important. Drivers struck by a rideshare vehicle may need full replacement value for their cars. Passengers may have personal items—like laptops, phones, or work equipment—that were destroyed in the crash. These claims ensure victims are not left paying out of pocket for damaged property.

The most devastating cases involve wrongful death. Families who lose a loved one in a rideshare accident can pursue damages for funeral expenses, lost financial support, and the profound emotional loss that comes with an untimely death. These cases often involve substantial damages because the harm extends across a lifetime.

Why Do You Need a Lawyer for a Rideshare Crash?

Uber and Lyft have vast resources and defense teams dedicated to minimizing payouts. Victims who go it alone quickly find themselves stonewalled by insurers or pressured into accepting a fraction of what their case is worth. A lawyer shifts that balance immediately.

The first role of an attorney is to gather critical evidence. That means getting police reports, pulling medical records, securing witness statements, and demanding electronic data from the rideshare company.

Uber and Lyft track every ride in detail—the driver’s location, speed, and app activity before the crash. Accessing and interpreting that data can make the difference between a denied claim and a strong case for liability.

Attorneys also map out the insurance landscape. Insurers may try to exploit these distinctions to reduce or deny claims. A lawyer identifies which policy applies, forces the insurer to honor it, and ensures no coverage gaps are left unchallenged.

Once the evidence and coverage are established, the attorney moves to negotiation. Insurance adjusters are trained to minimize payouts, often questioning the severity of injuries or arguing that medical treatment was excessive.

Lawyers counter these tactics with documented proof—doctor testimony, expert reports, and financial calculations that reflect the real impact of the accident. Strong negotiation often leads to settlements that reflect the true value of the claim.

When insurers refuse to settle fairly, attorneys are prepared to take the case to court. Filing a lawsuit raises the stakes for Uber, Lyft, and their insurers, forcing them to defend their positions before a judge or jury. The willingness to go to trial often compels higher settlement offers, but if necessary, trial verdicts can hold the companies accountable in full.

The practical benefit of legal representation is matched by the personal one. Victims don’t have to manage paperwork, deadlines, or hostile insurance adjusters while recovering from injuries. Instead, the lawyer takes on the fight, leaving the client free to focus on healing.

Against companies as powerful as Uber and Lyft, legal representation isn’t just helpful—it’s essential. Without it, victims are at the mercy of insurers whose only goal is to pay as little as possible. With it, they have a chance to recover everything the law allows and hold rideshare corporations accountable for the harm their drivers cause.

If you’ve been injured in a car accident with an Uber or Lyft driver, the attorneys at PARRIS Law Firm can help you understand your rights and work to secure compensation. Contact us today to discuss your options.

People Also Ask

Can I file a claim if the rideshare driver was not at fault? Yes. As a passenger, you can still recover damages even if another driver caused the crash. The at-fault driver’s insurance is pursued first. If that coverage is not enough, Uber or Lyft’s uninsured/underinsured motorist policy may apply. This ensures passengers are protected regardless of who caused the collision.

What if the rideshare driver didn’t have proper insurance? Uber and Lyft require their drivers to carry personal auto insurance, but if a driver fails to maintain coverage, the company’s policy can still apply during app use. This prevents victims from being left without recourse. The challenge is proving the driver’s status in the app at the time of the crash to trigger company coverage.

Can rideshare companies be held responsible for driver fatigue? Potentially. Uber and Lyft allow drivers to spend long hours on the road, and fatigue is a major cause of accidents. If company policies encourage excessive driving without rest, victims may argue that corporate decisions contributed to unsafe conditions. These claims can open the door to holding Uber or Lyft directly accountable beyond insurance coverage.

What happens if I was injured while getting in or out of a rideshare? Injuries don’t always happen while the car is moving. If you’re hurt while entering or exiting an Uber or Lyft—such as being struck by another vehicle or tripping due to a driver’s unsafe stop—you may still have a valid claim. Coverage depends on whether the trip was active in the app at the time of the incident.

Here are more articles related to the same topic

Tell us how we can help.

If you need immediate assistance, please call our office at (661) 441-3989 and ask to speak with someone in our Intake Department available 24/7.

Alex and Adriana